Iowa Stars 17
Notice: All logos on this page are included within the parameters of 17 U.S.C. § 107, which states that the reproduction of a copyrighted work for purposes of criticism and/or comment is not an infringement of copyright. No challenge to the copyrights of these logos is intended by their inclusion here.


HOME
RULES
RANKINGS
HISTORY
FEEDBACK
FRIENDS AND FAVORITES
OTHER



TEAMS

Teams with asterisks are not yet posted

Alaska Aces
Albany River Rats
Amarillo Gorillas
Arizona Sundogs
Augusta Lynx
Austin Ice Bats
Bakersfield Condors
Binghamton Senators
Bloomington Prairie Thunder
Bossier/Shreveport Mudbugs
Bridgeport Sound Tigers
Charlotte Checkers
Chicago Wolves
Cincinnati Cyclones
Colorado Eagles
Columbia Inferno
Columbus Cottonmouths
Corpus Christi Rayz
Dayton Bombers
Elmira Jackals
Fayetteville Fire Antz
Flint Generals
Florida Everblades
Fort Wayne Komets
Fresno Falcons
Grand Rapids Griffins
Gwinnett Gladiators
Hamilton Bulldogs
Hartford Wolf Pack
Hershey Bears
Houston Aeros
Huntsville Havoc
Idaho Steelheads
Iowa Stars
Jacksonville Barracudas
Johnstown Chiefs
Kalamazoo Wings
Knoxville Ice Bears
Lake Erie Monsters
Laredo Bucks
Las Vegas Wranglers
Lowell Devils
Manchester Monarchs
Manitoba Moose
Milwaukee Admirals
Mississippi RiverKings
Mississippi Sea Wolves
Muskegon Fury
New Mexico Scorpions
Norfolk Admirals
Odessa Jackalopes
Oklahoma City Blazers
Pensacola Ice Pilots
Peoria Rivermen
Philadelphia Phantoms
Phoenix RoadRunners
Port Huron Icehawks
Portland Pirates
Providence Bruins
Quad City Flames
Reading Royals
Richmond Renegades
Rio Grande Valley Killer Bees
Rochester Americans
Rockford IceHogs
Rocky Mountain Rage
San Antonio Rampage
South Carolina Stingrays
Springfield Falcons
Stockton Thunder
Syracuse Crunch
Texas Brahmas
Texas Wildcatters
Toronto Marlies
Trenton Devils
Tulsa Oilers
Twin City Cyclones
Utah Grizzlies
Victoria Salmon Kings
Wheeling Nailers
Wichita Thunder
Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins
Worcester Sharks
Youngstown SteelHounds
If you are an American, then I can name just about any region in the United States and you know the stereotype about people from there. The South? Uneducated, backwards, and racist. New York City? Rude and arrogant. California? Politically correct and New Agey. Texas? Like the South but with an itchy trigger finger. My point here is not to say that these stereotypes are accurate, but simply that they are well-known. And if I mention the Midwest, you probably have a stereotype there as well, and that stereotype probably involves words like "boring" and "unimaginative".

This stereotype, like the stereotype of the New Agey Californian or the racist Southern, may or may not be accurate. But one thing is for certain: neither the name nor the logo for this team do anything to dispel this stereotype.

Let's start with the name. Stars is the second most common name in the history of North American professional hockey, with thirteen teams having used that name. (The most common is Blades, with fourteen. And in case you're wondering, the other highly common names include the Falcons with twelve, the Knights with eleven, and a five-way tie between Clippers, Flyers, Rangers, Saints, and Tigers, all with ten). Using such a common name is not a mark of originality. Neither is using the name of your NHL affiliate. And to make it even more lemming-like, it's coming at a time when the trend is for more AHL teams to start using their affiliates' names (of the six AHL teams that use the same name as their affiliate, four of them have been doing so for less than five years).

And then there's the logo. Of the six aforementioned teams, only Providence and Worcester use a logo more similar to the affiliate's logo than the Iowa Stars do. Admittedly, using a different logo isn't necessarily a good thing (check out the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins and Binghamton Senators for two very good, very bad examples). But such a logo would at least make people think you had an original bone in your body, which this logo does not do. The minor differences between this logo and Dallas' logo just make it worse, in fact. It's as if someone said, "Maybe if we tilt the logo and use a slightly different font, it'll be original!" No, it won't. It will be be so close to the original that people will have to put the two side by side to see the difference. If they had simply used the same logo, people would have figured they were deliberately trying to use the same logo. Instead, it looks like they were trying to use a different logo and failed.

And as if all this didn't pound home the notion that Iowa is not a bastion of originality, consider this: this isn't the first time a team in Des Moines has been called the Iowa Stars. A team in the Central Hockey League -- then the top affiliate minor league for the NHL -- used the name in the 1969-70 season. So here we have a team using a name that a) has been used before in the same place, b) is the name of its NHL affiliate, and c) is the second most common name for North American hockey teams. There is so little originality involved here that I was tempted to just take my review for the Providence Bruins and replace all instances of "Providence" with "Iowa". But I decided against it.

After all, I'm not from the Midwest.

Final Score: 17 points.
Penalties: Region (egregious), 5 pts; Name-Logo (quadruply-egregious), 7 pts; Offspring, 5 pts.
Bonuses: None.


This page Copyright ©2006 Scott D. Rhodes. All rights reserved